In a controversial decision that has sparked community debate, the Independent Liquor and Gaming Authority (ILGA) of New South Wales has rejected Aldi's application to sell alcohol at its store, citing concerns over potential health and crime impacts in the region.
Despite the backing of approximately 600 Goonellabah residents through a petition, the state’s watchdog said 'the social impact of approving the application may be detrimental to the well-being of the local or broader community'.
The local residents allege the concerns don't appear genuine given the presence of multiple other liquor stores operating unrestrictedly in the area and offering a wider range of alcohol.
Aldi proposed to allocate a 49 sqm area within its Goonellabah outlet for the sale of unrefrigerated alcohol products, including beers and wines.
The proposal argued that selling alcohol would meet the demands of the growing local population, offering a range of award-winning Aldi branded products. The company also pledged not to sell refrigerated alcoholic beverages to mitigate the risk of immediate consumption near the premises, asserting that their proposal would bring substantial public benefits like convenience, choice, and the introduction of new product lines.
Despite acknowledging Aldi as a fit and proper entity for liquor sales, and noting the supermarket's comprehensive plan for responsible service, the Authority pointed out the relatively high density of licensed outlets in the area and alarming crime and health data, insisting on the potential risks associated with introducing another alcohol-selling venue to a vulnerable community.
Concluding its detailed assessment, ILGA said the potential negative social impacts of granting the license would outweigh any proposed benefits, thereby not serving the public interest.
Aldi has the option to seek a formal review of this decision with the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, leaving the future of alcohol sales at the Goonellabah store uncertain.
