BOSTON – Physician-investigators at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) compared a chatbot's probabilistic reasoning to that of human clinicians. The findings, published in JAMA Network Open, suggest that artificial intelligence could serve as useful clinical decision support tools for physicians.
"Humans struggle with probabilistic reasoning, the practice of making decisions based on calculating odds," said the study's corresponding author Adam Rodman, MD, an internal medicine physician and investigator in the department of Medicine at BIDMC. "Probabilistic reasoning is one of several components of making a diagnosis, which is an incredibly complex process that uses a variety of different cognitive strategies. We chose to evaluate probabilistic reasoning in isolation because it is a well-known area where humans could use support."
Basing their study on a previously published national survey of more than 550 practitioners performing probabilistic reasoning on five medical cases, Rodman and colleagues fed the publicly available Large Language Model (LLM), Chat GPT-4, the same series of cases and ran an identical prompt 100 times to generate a range of responses.
The chatbot—just like the practitioners before them—was tasked with estimating the likelihood of a given diagnosis based on patients' presentation. Then, given test results such as chest radiography for pneumonia, mammography for breast cancer, stress test for coronary artery disease and a urine culture for urinary tract infection, the chatbot program updated its estimates.
When test results were positive, it was something of a draw; the chatbot was more accurate in making diagnoses than the humans in two cases, similarly accurate in two cases and less accurate in one case. But when tests came back negative, the chatbot shone, demonstrating more accuracy in making diagnoses than humans in all five cases.
"Humans sometimes feel the risk is higher than it is after a negative test result, which can lead to overtreatment, more tests and too many medications," said Rodman.
But Rodman is less interested in how chatbots and humans perform toe-to-toe than in how highly skilled physicians' performance might change in response to having these new supportive technologies available to them in the clinic, added Rodman. He and colleagues are looking into it.
"LLMs can't access the outside world – they aren't calculating probabilities the way that epidemiologists, or even poker players, do. What they're doing has a lot more in common with how humans make spot probabilistic decisions," he said. "But that's what is exciting. Even if imperfect, their ease of use and ability to be integrated into clinical workflows could theoretically make humans make better decisions," he said. "Future research into collective human and artificial intelligence is sorely needed."
Co-authors included Thomas A. Buckley, University of Massachusetts Amherst; Arun K. Manrai, PhD, Harvard Medical School; Daniel J. Morgan, MD, MS, University of Maryland School of Medicine.
Rodman reported receiving grants from the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation. Morgan reported receiving grants from the Department of Veterans Affairs, the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and the National Institutes of Health, and receiving travel reimbursement from the Infectious Diseases Society of America, the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America. The American College of Physicians and the World Heart Health Organization outside the submitted work. No other disclosures were reported.
About Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center is a leading academic medical center, where extraordinary care is supported by high-quality education and research. BIDMC is a teaching affiliate of Harvard Medical School, and consistently ranks as a national leader among independent hospitals in National Institutes of Health funding. BIDMC is the official hospital of the Boston Red Sox.
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center is a part of Beth Israel Lahey Health, a health care system that brings together academic medical centers and teaching hospitals, community and specialty hospitals, more than 4,800 physicians and 38,000 employees in a shared mission to expand access to great care and advance the science and practice of medicine through groundbreaking research and education.
