Unruly Stars Skew Sight of Distant Planets

University College London

'Temperamental' stars that brighten and dim over a matter of hours or days may be distorting our view of thousands of distant planets, suggests a new study led by UCL researchers.

decorative

Most of the information we have about planets beyond our solar system (exoplanets) comes from looking at dips in starlight as these planets pass in front of their host star.

This technique can give clues about the planet's size (by looking at how much starlight is blocked) and what its atmosphere is made of (by looking at how the planet changes the pattern of starlight that passes through it).

But a new study, published in The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series, concluded that fluctuations in the starlight due to hotter and colder regions on a star's surface may be distorting our interpretations of planets more than we previously thought.

The researchers looked at the atmospheres of 20 Jupiter- and Neptune-sized planets and found that the host stars' changeability distorted the data for about half of them.

If researchers did not properly account for these variations, the team said, they could misinterpret a range of features such as the planets' size, temperature and the composition of their atmospheres.

Lead author Dr Arianna Saba (UCL Physics & Astronomy), who did the work as part of her PhD at UCL, said: "These results were a surprise - we found more stellar contamination of our data than we were expecting. This is important for us to know. By refining our understanding of how stars' variability might affect our interpretations of exoplanets, we can improve our models and make smarter use of the much bigger datasets to come from missions including James Webb, Ariel and Twinkle."

Second author Alexandra (Alex) Thompson, a current PhD student at UCL Physics & Astronomy whose research focuses on exoplanet host stars, said: "We learn about exoplanets from the light of their host stars and it is sometimes hard to disentangle what is a signal from the star and what is coming from the planet.

"Some stars might be described as 'patchy' - they have a greater proportion of colder regions, which are darker, and hotter regions, which are brighter, on their surface. This is due to stronger magnetic activity.

"Hotter, brighter regions (faculae) emit more light and so, for instance, if a planet passes in front of the hottest part of the star, this might lead researchers to over-estimate how large the planet is, as it will seem to block out more of the star's light, or they might infer the planet is hotter than it is or has a denser atmosphere. The reverse is true if the planet passes in front of a cold starspot, making the planet appear 'smaller'.

"On the other hand, the reduction in emitted light from a starspot could even mimic the effect of a planet passing in front of a star, leading you to think there might be a planet when there is none. This is why follow up observations are so important to confirm exoplanet detections.

"These variations from the star can also distort estimates of how much water vapour, for instance, is in a planet's atmosphere. That is because the variations can mimic or obscure the signature of water vapour in the pattern of light at different wavelengths that reaches our telescopes."

  • Top: Artist's impression of a hot Jupiter planet orbiting close to one of the stars in the rich old star cluster Messier 67. Credit: ESO/L. Calçada. Source: ESO
  • Middle: Second author Alex Thompson's artistic representation of the HAT-P-11 system of which multiple observations were used in this study. The HAT-P-11 system consists of a cool host star that is much 'spottier' than our Sun orbited by a misaligned, transiting 'super-Neptune' HAT-P-11b and a non-transiting Jupiter-mass planet HAT-P-11c
  • /Public Release. This material from the originating organization/author(s) might be of the point-in-time nature, and edited for clarity, style and length. Mirage.News does not take institutional positions or sides, and all views, positions, and conclusions expressed herein are solely those of the author(s).View in full here.